Can a Creditor Challenge a Fraudulent Transfer in South Dakota?

When Debtors Move Assets to Avoid Paying and What You Can Do About It

Creditors often spend months or even years trying to collect money rightfully owed to them. But what happens when a debtor suddenly transfers property to a friend, family member, or business partner right before or during a collection attempt? If the move was made to shield assets from creditors, it could be considered a fraudulent transfer, and you may have legal options to reverse it.

In South Dakota, creditors are protected under the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act (UFTA), which allows them to challenge transfers made with the intent to hinder, delay, or defraud. If successful, you may be able to recover the asset itself or its value, even if it’s now in someone else’s hands.

What Is a Fraudulent Transfer?

A fraudulent transfer occurs when a debtor moves assets in an attempt to avoid creditors or legal judgments. This can include giving away property, selling something far below market value, or shifting ownership to a family member, all while knowing a creditor is trying to collect.

Under South Dakota law, there are two main types of fraudulent transfers:

  • Actual fraud: When the debtor intentionally transfers property to avoid paying a creditor. This requires proof of intent.
  • Constructive fraud: When the transfer may not have been done with direct intent, but the debtor received less than fair market value and was insolvent or became insolvent because of it.

Even if there’s no “smoking gun” showing that the debtor wanted to dodge a debt, a court can still deem a transfer fraudulent based on timing, the relationship between parties, or suspicious terms of the deal.

Common Red Flags for Fraudulent Transfers

Fraudulent transfers don’t always involve dramatic asset dumps. They often appear as ordinary transactions, but with telling details. Courts will consider several “badges of fraud” when evaluating whether a transfer was legitimate or designed to cheat creditors:

  • The transfer was to an insider (like a spouse, sibling, or business partner)
  • The debtor retained control over the property after the transfer
  • The transfer occurred shortly before or after a lawsuit was filed
  • The debtor was facing financial problems or was already insolvent
  • The asset was transferred for little or no value
  • The debtor became insolvent shortly after the transfer

If several of these signs are present, a court is more likely to view the transfer as fraudulent and allow the creditor to take action.

What Can a Creditor Do About a Fraudulent Transfer?

If you suspect a debtor has transferred assets improperly, South Dakota law gives you several remedies. With the help of a creditor’s rights attorney, you can file a claim to:

  • Reverse the transfer: The court can void the transaction and return the asset to the debtor’s estate, making it available for collection.
  • Attach other assets: If the original asset cannot be recovered, the court may allow you to go after other property of equal value.
  • Obtain a money judgment: In some cases, you can get a judgment against the transferee (the person who received the asset) if they were involved in the fraudulent scheme.

The UFTA gives courts broad power to help creditors recover what they’re owed, but it’s important to act quickly. There are deadlines (statutes of limitations) for bringing a claim, usually within four years of the transfer or within one year of when the transfer was discovered (or reasonably should have been discovered).

Proving a Fraudulent Transfer in Court

Successfully challenging a fraudulent transfer requires strong evidence and a clear legal strategy. You’ll need to show that the transfer meets one or more criteria under South Dakota’s UFTA and that the debtor was attempting to avoid a valid debt.

This might include:

  • Financial records showing the debtor’s insolvency at the time of transfer
  • Testimony or communications indicating the debtor’s intent
  • Property appraisals that show the transfer was below market value
  • Bank statements, contracts, and asset records

Because these cases often involve insider relationships or obscure financial trails, working with a knowledgeable creditor’s rights attorney is crucial. At Ogborn Mihm Quaintance, we know how to uncover hidden asset transfers and build solid cases on behalf of creditors.

How Creditors Can Protect Themselves Proactively

While you can’t always prevent a debtor from acting in bad faith, there are steps you can take to protect your rights from the outset of the lending or contract relationship:

  • Secure your debt with collateral when possible
  • Include provisions in contracts that require financial disclosures
  • Conduct regular credit and asset checks on high-risk accounts
  • Act quickly if payments stop or legal action becomes necessary

Early action gives you a better chance of freezing or recovering assets before they disappear or are transferred to third parties.

Contact Ogborn Mihm Quaintance for Legal Representation

Fraudulent transfers are frustrating, but they don’t have to leave you empty-handed. If you suspect that a debtor is trying to avoid payment by moving or hiding assets, legal remedies are available to hold them accountable and recover what you’re owed.

Contact us today to speak with a creditor’s rights attorney in Sioux Falls. We’ll help you evaluate the transfer, assess your options, and take swift action to protect your interests.

Recent Post

lawyer in suit malpractice
When you hire an attorney, you expect them to work solely in your best interests. That trust is at the […]
Read More
secured creditor middle aged man in suit lender
When creditors lend money or extend credit, they do so with the expectation that the borrower will repay the debt. […]
Read More
real estate agents
Real estate transactions are significant financial undertakings, whether you’re buying, selling, or leasing property. At the heart of every transaction […]
Read More
Ogborn logo with pattern
Address:
140 N. Phillips Ave. Suite 203
Sioux Falls, South Dakota 57104
Copyright © 2025 Ogborn Mihm Quaintance, PLLC | XML Sitemap | HTML Sitemap - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by:
Epic Web Results logo